How to Compare Two Mortgage Offers: Upfront Costs, Payments and Time HomeBuyersPath Caption-derived transcript of the original educational video. Fictional figures, not current lender quotes. AI narration. Readable text normalizes spacing around compound hyphens, percent signs, and the website address; spoken words and figures are preserved. Chapter labels show whole seconds; playback seeks to the exact first caption in each chapter. 0:00 — Three questions, not one rate Two mortgage offers arrive. One has a lower interest rate. The other needs less cash at closing. Which one deserves a closer look? Start with three questions. What do you pay upfront? What do you pay each month? And how long might you keep the loan? We will compare a fictional pair in the free HomeBuyersPath tool, then look at a separate time horizon example. We will also catch a subtle mistake. A disclosed five year number can leave a lender credit outside the comparison you think you are making. The goal is to understand the trade-offs and ask better lender questions. These invented rates are not current quotes, and this walkthrough will not choose a mortgage for you. 0:42 — Make the comparison fair Our main example starts with a $400,000 home, $80,000 down, and a $320,000 mortgage. Both loans are 30-year fixed rate loans. This is a different down payment from our cash planning video's example. Both offers also assume a $5,000 deposit already paid, $5,000 in other closing costs, no mortgage insurance, and $500 a month in estimated escrow. Those shared assumptions help isolate the loan pricing differences. For your own offers, compare the loan amount, term, product, and issue dates. Check whether each rate is locked and when the lock expires. A 15-year loan and a 30-year loan answer different payment questions. Different tax estimates can also make two payments look less comparable than their headline numbers suggest. 1:34 — Start with the actual figures On HomeBuyersPath, open Guides and choose how to compare loan estimates. Select Compare your two loan estimates. The tool opens with these fictional offers. You can examine them before choosing use my offers to enter information from your own forms. Copy each figure from the named page and section. Leave an unknown amount blank. A blank is different from a disclosed zero. The tool compares fixed rate offers and calculates differences from what you enter. It does not verify your documents or approve a loan. No account or document upload is required. Your entries stay in this page's browser memory, so reloading starts a new example. If you need a record, the tool offers print or save as PDF. Our demonstrations use fictional figures only. 2:23 — Read the price behind the rate Offer A has a 6.25% interest rate and $3,200 in points. One point is 1% of the loan amount. On this $320,000 loan, that is $3,200. Offer B has a 6.5% rate and no points. A point does not buy a universal rate reduction. Ask the same lender what its alternative quote would be with different points or credits. Also watch the nesting of the costs. Points are already included in origination charges in Section A. Section A is already included in total loan costs in Section D. Adding all three figures together would count some charges more than once. Compare the totals, then open the components to understand why they differ. 3:11 — Account for credits and cash still due Offer A has $7,200 in total loan costs and no lender credit. Offer B has $4,000 in loan costs and a fully usable $2,000 lender credit. For this comparison, subtracting that credit leaves $2,000 of net loan costs for B. A therefore needs $5,200 more upfront in net loan costs. The complete cash-to-close figures are $87,200 for A and $82,000 for B. They also account for the shared down payment, other costs, and paid deposit. Do not subtract the deposit or credit again. In another transaction, cash-to-close differences could include different down payments, taxes, or prepaid amounts. They are not automatically the price of a lower rate. Lender credits can also have different reasons, so ask how each one relates to the rate and fees. 4:05 — Separate payment assumptions from pricing Now compare monthly principal and interest. A shows $1,970.30. B shows $2,022.62. A is $52.32 lower each month. The total payment adds the same estimated escrow in this example. Real offers may use different taxes, insurance, or mortgage insurance assumptions. A smaller estimate for those items does not itself mean the lender offers cheaper financing. Keep the interest rate and APR separate too. The interest rate describes the borrowing rate without upfront fees. APR is a broader disclosed measure that includes certain additional charges. It is not every closing expense and it is not the rate to substitute when calculating the monthly payment. Review both alongside the actual costs and terms. 4:59 — Read the five-year measure carefully Page 3 of the loan estimate has an in five years comparison. One number includes principal, interest, mortgage insurance, and loan costs. The other shows principal paid off. Subtract principal once to isolate the interest, any mortgage insurance, and loan costs in that disclosed measure. For A, $125,418 minus $21,321 equals $104,097. For B, $125,357 minus $20,445 equals $104,912. A is $815 lower on that displayed measure, but pause before calling A cheaper overall. In this fictional pair, those totals include gross Section D loan costs. B's $2,000 lender credit is separate. It has not been netted in that subtraction. Keep the real disclosed figures unchanged and examine the credit alongside them. 6:03 — Keep the credit in the full comparison Here is a separate illustration of why that distinction matters. We keep the same loan pair, assume B's credit is fully usable, and hold the other costs equal. There is no mortgage insurance. Starting with the rounded disclosed figures, B's $104,912, less its $2,000 credit, is $102,912. Compared with A's $104,097, B is $1,185 lower on this limited interest plus loan cost comparison after the credit. That is educational arithmetic outside the calculator, not a corrected official disclosure, or a recommendation. It leaves out the time value of money and other ownership costs. Never subtract a credit twice from an already-net figure. Ask your lender to show a complete comparison for your actual costs and possible payoff date. 7:01 — Test the time you might keep the loan Next, switch to a separate, simpler example. These are not Offer A and Offer B. Suppose one loan costs $2,400 more after applicable lender credits, and its monthly principal and interest payment is $60 lower. Other assumptions stay fixed. The upfront difference excludes down payments, deposits, taxes, and escrow. $2,400 divided by $60 is 40 months to recover the extra cash through lower payments. At 24 months, the payment reductions total $1,440, leaving $960 unrecovered. At 48 months, the total is $2,880 or $480 ahead in cash flow. At 84 months, it is $5,040 or $2,640 ahead. These are cash flow checkpoints, not full borrowing cost results. Principal balances, mortgage insurance, other costs, and the value of keeping cash can change the decision. 8:03 — Take the right questions to each lender Choose a shorter possibility, your most likely plan, and a longer possibility for keeping the loan. Those are scenarios, not predictions. A future refinance is uncertain and could bring new costs. Ask each lender for upfront charges, total borrowing costs, and the remaining balance at those dates with credits explained and consistent assumptions. The HomeBuyersPath comparator uses the disclosed five-year figures. It does not calculate arbitrary holding periods or a refinance outcome. Use the guide's questions for that wider conversation. If a quote uses a lower tax or insurance estimate, ask why. If a credit changes, ask what else changes with it. A useful comparison leaves you knowing which amounts differ, which assumptions are shared, and which questions still need an answer. 8:55 — Make the next comparison useful Open homebuyerspath.com, choose guides, and select how to compare loan estimates. Follow the worked examples, then open the free comparison tool with your own confirmed figures nearby. Compare the rate's upfront price, the monthly payment assumptions, and the cost over the time you might keep the loan. Keep a record of lender explanations and confirm any changed terms before choosing. The optional paid Excel toolkit can help organize several homes and offers, but you do not need to buy it to use this free guide or calculator. These examples are education, not loan approval, current lender quotes, or payment instructions. Your next useful step is a clearer set of figures and questions, not choosing the lowest number without understanding what it includes.